Pros and cons list maker: weigh a decision and see the result
This pros and cons list maker does more than two columns: write down your arguments, give each a weight from 1 to 5, and you see immediately which side wins, how close it is and how many points are missing for a tie. Save the chart as a PNG to keep or share.
Source: Wikipedia – Decisional balance sheet (Benjamin Franklin’s weighing of reasons for and against a decision). Updated: .
How it is calculated
A good pros and cons list does not just count arguments, it weighs them: one important argument outweighs three minor ones. The tool adds up the weights on both sides and shows you where the scale tips.
How to use it
- Phrase the decision as a question at the top.
- Write arguments for and against, one per line.
- Add a weight after a semicolon: 1 = minor, 3 = noticeable, 5 = decisive.
- Read the balance and save the chart if you want to show it to someone.
Why weights matter
Benjamin Franklin described in a 1772 letter to Joseph Priestley how he listed reasons in two columns and crossed out arguments of equal weight against each other. The balance here does the same: if you only count bullet points, the length of the lists decides. With weights, what really matters to you decides.
How to read the result
The total bar shows each side’s share of the points. When both sides are close, the tool tells you how many points are missing for a tie – a sign that the decision still depends on gut feeling or extra information. A list is no substitute for advice, but it helps to organise your thoughts. All entries stay in your browser.
Frequently asked questions
How do I make a pros and cons list?
Enter the question, write arguments for and against one per line, and add a weight from 1 to 5 after a semicolon. The tool adds up the weights and draws the chart.
What does the weight of an argument mean?
1 means minor, 3 noticeable, 5 decisive. Without a number, 3 is used.
Does that make the decision for me?
No. The list shows what wins according to your own weights. If the result feels wrong, an argument is often missing – or a weight is off.
Is there a printable pros and cons list template?
The chart can be saved as PNG or SVG and printed on A4. With empty fields you get a blank template.
How many arguments make sense?
Usually three to seven per side. The chart shows the eight strongest arguments per side; all of them count towards the balance.
Are my arguments saved?
No, nothing is uploaded. The list is calculated in your browser and stays on your device.
Sources and legal basis
As of: · Editorial policy
Related tools
- Decision matrix calculatorBuild a decision matrix online: weight your criteria, score the options, see the winner, how stable it is and save the chart as PNG. Free, no sign-up.
- SWOT analysis maker: template with chartMake a SWOT analysis online: enter strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats, get strategy questions and save the four-box chart as PNG. Free, private.
- Eisenhower matrix template: sort tasks by urgent and importantFree Eisenhower matrix template: enter tasks with importance and urgency, let them sort into four boxes automatically and save the matrix as a PNG to print.
- Spin the Wheel Online – Free Wheel GeneratorSpin the wheel with your own names, numbers or ideas. Set adjustable odds, remove winners, share by link. Truly random, free, no sign-up.
- Flip a coin: heads or tails?Flip a coin online: heads or tails, 1 to 1,000 flips per toss, your own labels for both sides, live stats and streaks. Cryptographic randomness, no sign-up.
- Mind map makerMake a mind map online: type your ideas as an outline, press Tab to indent and the layout is drawn for you. Export PNG or SVG, saved in your browser. Free.
- Margin calculatorMargin calculator: enter cost or price plus margin, markup or profit and get the rest – with totals by quantity and a margin table for volume price tiers.
- CBM calculatorCBM calculator for shipping: enter length, width and height in cm, mm, m, inches or feet plus the number of cartons and get cubic meters and cubic feet.
- Employee Turnover Rate CalculatorEmployee turnover rate calculator: enter separations and headcount for a month, quarter or year to get the rate, the annual figure and retention. Free.